A divorced janitor, a 27-year employee and the mother of a seventeen-year old son with the mental capacity of an 18-month old, fails to report for mandatory overtime one Saturday when her son’s caregiver could not work because of a sick child. She calls twice and leaves a message for her manager. She gets fired.
As I read about this woman in Reshaping the Work-Family Debate: Why Men and Class Matter by Joan Williams, I wondered what this mother’s take would be on Jonah Goldberg’s recent proclamation in the Los Angeles Times that “Feminism as a ‘movement’ in America is largely played out. The work here is mostly done.” In a piece titled, “Taking feminism overseas” Goldberg goes on to declare that “Even the fight for “pay equity” is an argument about statistics, lagging cultural indicators and the actual choices liberated women make — to take time away from paid jobs to raise their kids (never-married women without kids earn more than men) or to work in occupations like the nonprofit sector that pay less.”
The only reason Goldberg and others can make this “choices” claim with a straight face is because the bias against women is no longer as overt as it once was– no more separate salary schedules for men and women. Much of the bias has gone underground, way underground, into our subconscious and into the unquestioned structure of our workplaces around the way men have typically worked in the past. Jobs are designed for a man who has a wife to care for family; 50-hour workweeks, mandatory overtime, inflexible schedules that can change at the last minute, and little or no sick time.
When mothers, who do still shoulder most of the responsibility for family care, find it impossible to fit this mold the resulting stories don’t sound much like “choices liberated women make.” They sound like discrimination. In fact, Williams and her colleagues at the WorkLife Law Center have documented a 400% increase in lawsuits involving family responsibilities discrimination “showing how mothers and other caregivers are pushed out of jobs they want – and need.”
Multiple studies demonstrate that motherhood in particular triggers automatic bias that has a direct impact on pay and promotions. In one study, people given identical resumes that differed only in that one listed membership in the PTA and the other didn’t, the mothers were 79% less likely to be hired and 100% less likely to be promoted, and offered $11,000 less in salary. In another study, people rated businesswomen has highly competent, yet they rated the competence of housewives as comparable to the elderly, blind, “retarded,” and disabled.
Bias like this is harder to see, unintentional, and far easier to dismiss as a result of mothers’ “choices.” Legislation like the Paycheck Fairness Act is important not only as a punitive measure for those individuals or organizations that may consciously discriminate against women. Legislation also serves to motivate organizations to create systems for hiring, evaluating and scheduling employees that control for the automatic bias that has negatively impacts women and their pay.
Though an arbitrator reinstated the janitor, the work here in the U.S. to achieve pay equity for women is far from done.
- RT @LATstevelopez: A proud moment for California: Justice Scalia impugns our entire state http://t.co/xkB6n78lL7 about 4 days ago from Twitter Web Client ReplyRetweetFavorite
- Female lawyers take firmer stand on equality in the workplace @LAtimes by @AbcarianLAT ftrng @JoanCWilliams http://t.co/76Bkq18mWR about 4 days ago from Hootsuite ReplyRetweetFavorite
- YAYYY!!! Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules, 5-4 @NYTimes http://t.co/iHiHFXxmmG about 4 days ago from Hootsuite ReplyRetweetFavorite
- Wow. A must read > Bryan Stevenson on Charleston and Our Real Problem with Race | @MarshallProj http://t.co/DMiTCCt7aJ about 6 days ago from Hootsuite ReplyRetweetFavorite
- Happy #FathersDay @JerryMaschka! You're the best! http://t.co/PTUoiq8DTn about 1 week ago from Twitter Web Client ReplyRetweetFavorite
- @DeltaAssist Ok. Prob won't get there early if we don't know. But if we do I will ask at tckting thnx!! about 1 week ago from Twitter for iPhone in reply to DeltaAssist ReplyRetweetFavorite
- @DeltaAssist Just DM you, sounds like looking for vols for our flight tomorrow nite and we could take earlier flight about 1 week ago from Twitter for iPhone in reply to DeltaAssist ReplyRetweetFavorite
Remodeling Motherhood offers fresh perspective on mothers, fathers, money, marriage and work paired with tools to remodel and improve the lives of parents and families.
NewsletterSign-up for Kristin’s email list for premium content available exclusively to subscribers.